ACUVUE OASYS® vs ACUVUE® MOIST – Comparison

*** Note: This article was written based on my personal experience and opinions which backed by some facts which are referenced in the article below. I did not intend this to be a medical article nor am I a qualified medical professional. I would recommend discussing this with your doctor if there are any questions around what was written. ***

Introduction

I am an regular contact lens wearer, I would wear contacts whenever I am out. When I first had interests in contact lens, it was when I was in my early teens. It was a very bad experience the least to say.  The doctor forced me to take the contact lens home, after I told them it was not comfortable for me and I rather have glasses.  I remember him putting the lens in my eyes for me to make it work. The contact lens would irritate me so bad that I could not wear them after 2 days of wearing them. I remember having headaches sitting in class and I felt like I wanted to rip my eyes out with them in.

To be fair, I cannot remember if I received any trial pairs and those were different times. I was very young, so I did not bother dealing with them again. Perhaps the medical industry did not make it as easy to return them as they do now which is why the optometrist reacted that way.

Either way, my perception had been skewed and was hesitant to try contacts again. It was not until I was in my early 20s, when my vision had gotten worse and my glasses were getting thicker which made it very challenging when training martial arts and playing sports.




Finally Contacts Lens

It was my luck that I mustered up the strength and went to my eye doctor who recommended ACUVUE Advance and then later ACUVUE OASYS® Brand Contact Lenses with HYDRACLEAR® PLUS Technology. From that day forward, I have been a contact lens wearer and I have to admit that it seemed like the greatest feeling ever.

My vision has been pretty consistent hovering around -3.25 on both eyes.

The Effects of Wearing Contact Lens

Over time, I started to experience dry eyes after 6 hours of daily wear. I started to notice this after 4-5 years. On average, I wear contacts up to 10 hours, allowing my eyes to rest once I get home and resort to my glasses.

For temporarily relief, there are contact lenses re-wetting drops that can help. I have used TheraTears Eye Drops for Contacts, Amo Blink Contacts Lubricating Eye Drops and Bausch + Lomb Renu Multiplus Lubricating And Rewetting Soft Eye Contact Lens Drops.

 

I did find relief resting my eyes and adding lubricant eye drops when my contacts are removed. The Refresh Optive Advanced were very good. It provided the much needed hydration and best when stored in the refrigerator. There are many other versions that were just as good or better. I personally liked the viles much better than the bottles.

My other personal favorite is TheraTears. They work just as well. It may be worth trying them to see which you prefer.




Switch to Daily Disposals

Eventually, my optometrist would advise to switch from 2-week disposals to daily disposals (1-Day ACUVUE® MOIST is a daily lens made with LACREON® Technology) and reduce my contact lens wear as much as possible. The daily option was to ensure I’m getting clean lens in-and-out. To be honest, I much prefer daily disposals since it feels much fresher and I don’t have to worry about any contamination. While using the 2-week disposals, it did save me a few bucks and I did not have to worry about running out of supplies so quickly. Here are some good disinfecting cleaning solutions which worked well for me for ensuring my soft contact lens were clean and fresh when they were ready to be worn.

Clear Care Plus Cleaning and Disinfecting Solution

Opti-Free Puremoist Multi-Purpose Disinfecting Solution

renu Advanced Formula Multi-Purpose Eye Contact Lens Solution

I have been warned by my eye doctor that I should limit my contact lens wear when possible since it’s not good to wear them all the time. The doctor did not go into detail as to why, and my curiosity probed me to dig further and came across some articles which alarmed me.




Long Term Contact Lens Wear Effects

The short version is that wearing contacts for a long time can starve your eyes of oxygen; the contact lens would act as a barrier to the oxygen supply, so extensive wear can potentially starve the cornea of oxygen. The damage will not be apparent to the naked eye, and only when the optometrist used a special microscope. One risk mentioned was corneal neovascularisation, the body will try to compensate for lack of oxygen in the eyes by growing new blood vessels and your eyes would have new blood vessels which could turn the cornea opaque and threaten the your sight.

I personally have been told that I have scarring around my eyes which is outside of the cornea and this doesn’t affect my vision. When reducing contact lens wear, it caused the new blood vessels to collapse, and caused the scarring. This condition is more common with soft lenses, made of water-containing plastic. The lens which are gas permeable, while less flexible, it allows for more oxygen. The latest contact lens type known as silicone hydrogels, will allow more oxygen to pass through to the cornea, making them healthier. (see references)

Both ACUVUE OASYS® Brand Contact Lenses with HYDRACLEAR® PLUS Technology and 1-Day ACUVUE® MOIST is a daily lens made with LACREON® Technology – are made with hydrol gel polymers.




ACUVUE OASYS vs ACUVUE® MOIST – My Comparison

I have used the Acuvue brand for over a decade and I have no major complaints. Between the dailies, ACUVUE OASYS® and ACUVUE® MOIST, I personally found more comfort using the ACUVUE OASYS®.

While the ACUVUE® MOIST offered much comfort, I have started to feel like my eyes were drier after 6 hours of usage. Whereas, the ACUVUE OASYS®  feels much thinner.

Let’s review the specs in more detail:

Water Content

Based on the specs below, the ACUVUE® MOIST has more water content with 58% and the ACUVUE OASYS® is at 38%.

UV Blocking

ACUVUE OASYS® is 96.1 UVA and 99% UVB, whereas, ACUVUE® MOIST blocks on average 82% of UVA and 97% UVB.

Lens Material

ACUVUE® MOIST is made of etafilcon A (Ionic Hydrogel Polymers), which has a high water rating and Oxygen transmit-ability of 23.8-28 Dk/t. ACUVUE OASYS® is made of senofilcon (Silicone Hydrogel Polymers) with a high Oxygen transmit-ability of 103-147 Dk/t. 

Oxygen transmitability is the degree to which oxygen may pass through a particular material of a given thickness.

Even though the ACUVUE® MOIST has a higher water content, the oxygen transmitability is greater with the ACUVUE OASYS®  even though the center thickness is slightly thicker on the ACUVUE OASYS® .


Here’s a quick snapshot using the Acuvue Product Spec Sheets.

Comparison – Acuvue Moist vs Acuvue Oasys

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


My Final Thoughts

I have found the ACUVUE OASYS®  to be more comfortable than the ACUVUE® MOIST. I believe the higher oxygen transmitability ratings and Oasys senofilcon A material made a difference. The lens are made to lock in hydration to create the “no lens” feel.  One issue I had with the ACUVUE® MOIST was to make sure I apply some rewetting eye drops before I put my contacts in. However, with the ACUVUE OASYS® with HYDRACLEAR® PLUS Technology, it already comes packaged with saline solution which is much similar to the salinity of actual tear film and this makes it easier to put the contact lens in. I personally found this to prolong the duration in which my eyes feel dry.  Last benefit I found with the ACUVUE OASYS®  is 14.3 mm it’s size in diameter is one of the larger contact lenses on the market. It provides a bit more comfort when it’s placed over the cornea compared to the ACUVUE® MOIST at 14.2 mm.

I think either way, this may come down to personal preference. Before I receive my trial pair of the ACUVUE OASYS® , I read a lot of reviews online which some people would prefer one over the other. My recommendation is to get your own trial pair and see which works better for you.




Author: thatguyr

1 thought on “ACUVUE OASYS® vs ACUVUE® MOIST – Comparison

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *